Historic Roof Replacement in Montclair from $5.50. On an 1895 planned neighborhood, what the roof looks like from the street is part of the job. Free inspection and a written quote.
The most architecturally ambitious housing covered on this site, and the place where a roof is most likely to be a designed object rather than a covering. Detail work itemized separately from area is not a preference here, it is the only way to produce a quote that means anything.
Halcyon Park was laid out in 1895 as a planned community of cottages, ponds and common ground, and it still reads that way from the street. Roofs on housing of that age and character are not simply a covering: shape, color and the detail at the eaves are part of what the house is.



The covering prices like any architectural shingle roof, $5.50 to $8.00 per square foot. What makes a period roof expensive is everything that is not field: valleys, dormers, eaves detailing and roof shapes with several planes. On this housing that detail is itemized separately, because pricing it by area produces a number that will not survive the first day. Assume the top of the ranges. Staging on a sloping plot, hand-formed detail on an ambitious roof, and a decent chance of a large array on the south-facing slope. A Montclair quote priced on area alone will be wrong by a wide margin.
Halcyon Park is a historic district laid out in 1895. Whether a municipal historic review applies to a roof, and what it covers, is confirmed with the township before the work is booked -- we do not tell you on a web page that we know.
Boards with gaps between them hold a nail differently from modern sheeting, and any that have to be made good are a real cost. Established by lifting a covering, not by assuming.
Shape, color and the line at the eaves read from the street on a house like these. Getting that wrong is not a technical failure and it is still a failure, so it gets settled before anything is ordered.
The most expensive roofs covered on this site, and for reasons that have nothing to do with the covering. Sloping plots mean staging rather than ladders; ambitious roof shapes mean valleys, dormers and hand-formed detail; and solar arrays on large south-facing slopes are common enough that the removal cost should be assumed until checked.
Montclair and Halcyon Park are where this site's prices stop tracking roof area and start tracking the number of details on the roof.
Worth knowing before you start ringing round, particularly if there are panels involved.
Northern roofs fail at the edges in the freeze. Water backs up under the courses at the eaves, freezes, lifts them, and the ceiling below stains during the first thaw -- so the calls arrive in a cluster, in the same two weeks, and the roof that could have been done comfortably in September becomes an emergency in February.
Assume the top of every range here.
Large south-facing slopes on substantial houses make this the most likely place on this site to find a big array over a tired roof.
Ambitious roof shapes mean more valleys per square foot, and valleys are where shingle roofs fail.
On a sloping plot a flat roof frequently discharges onto ground that falls away from the house, which is good -- or towards it, which is not.
On a sloping plot the garage is frequently built into the hill with one wall below grade, and that changes the diagnosis completely.
Detached township stock. Count the panels first.
Mixed use, flat roofs, parapets. Access first.
Pre-1940. Board sheathing and no ice barrier.
The biggest roofs, and the biggest arrays on them.
An 1895 planned district. Appearance is the brief.
Big Victorian roofs, and slate on a fair number.
Denser and more multi-family. Unit count decides it.
Asked on every job of this kind. Answered here.
Possibly, and we establish it rather than assume it. New Jersey municipalities may operate a historic preservation commission whose approval is required for exterior changes visible from the public way. We confirm the position with the township before the work is booked, including when the answer is that none is needed.
Because most of the cost is not field. Valleys, dormers, eaves detailing and multiple roof planes are all hand-worked, and a roof with six valleys takes far longer than a plain gable of the same area. That is why detail is itemized separately from area here.
No. The inspection is free, the written quote is free, and neither carries an obligation. The survey includes counting the array and giving you an honest estimate of how much life the covering has left, which is worth having even if you use somebody else. What we will not do is give you a number at the curb.
$250 to $350 per panel in New Jersey -- roughly $5,000 to $6,500 on a 26-panel system and $4,500 to $9,500 across the normal range of residential systems. That covers the electrical disconnect, removal and labeling, storage while the roof is open, reinstallation, reconnection and a production check. It adds four to seven days to the job.
An architectural asphalt roof runs $9,500 to $26,000, with most 2,000 square foot houses at $12,000 to $18,000 installed. Per square foot that is $5.50 to $8.00 for architectural and $4.50 to $6.50 for three-tab. If there is a solar array on the roof, add $4,500 to $9,500 and four to seven days.
Any array counted and priced separately, not buried in a rate. Both sequences costed, so the cheaper order is obvious.